Founded by Stefano Vaccara

Subscribe for only $6/Year
  • Login

Editor in Chief: Giampaolo Pioli

VNY La Voce di New York

The First Italian English Digital Daily in the US

English Editor: Grace Russo Bullaro

  • English Edition
  • Letters
  • New York
  • U.N.
  • News
  • People
  • Entertainment
  • Arts
  • Lifestyles
  • Food & Wine
  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Italian Edition
No Result
View All Result
VNY
  • English Edition
  • Letters
  • New York
  • U.N.
  • News
  • People
  • Entertainment
  • Arts
  • Lifestyles
  • Food & Wine
  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Italian Edition
No Result
View All Result
VNY La Voce di New York
No Result
View All Result
in
News
June 16, 2020
in
News
June 16, 2020
0

Not Every Statue is Fascist or Racist: Columbus Does Not Share Rizzo’s Values

Before taking down statues, we need to ask why were they erected? The Italian-Americans’ motivations for Columbus were and are legitimate to this day

Stefano LuconibyStefano Luconi
Being Italian American: Why Columbus Day Gives Me a Headache

Christopher Columbus and Mother Cabrini (Illustration by Antonella Martino )

Time: 5 mins read

In Italiano

After the authoritative contribution of Professor William J. Connell, I would like to take advantage of the hospitality of La Voce di New York to participate in the debate on the iconoclastic fury that the brutal and unjustified killing of George Floyd has unleashed not only in the United States, but on a global scale, against the alleged symbols of white domination as well as of the oppression, if not altogether, of the genocide of people of color. As a manifestation of an emotional mass anger, the tearing down and disfigurement of the monuments that we have witnessed in the last few days appear  lacking in any capability for discernment and, above all, they do not seem to be able to comprehend the multiple motivations that led to the erection of the statues of whose presence we  want to free ourselves from today. In other words, to make use of a colloquial expression, those who want these statues eliminated mix the wheat with the chaff. In particular, they place on the same plane the deliberate celebration of implicit forms as well as explicit forms of racism and the expression of a public recognition to individuals who have exhibited questionable behaviors and  actually reprehensible if judged by the ethical criteria of our present time, instead of a coeval moral  measure of evaluation.

Christopher Columbus statue destroyed in Minneapolis. (Image from Youtube)

To the first type of monument belong the statues erected to confederate generals like Robert E. Lee. These are taken as a symbol not so much for the presumed military and war-like skills of those who fought for the Confederacy in the war against the Union, but for their strenuous defense of slavery on the part of the Southern society. It is no accident that many of these statues were not erected immediately after the conclusion of the Civil War, but in the successive period of the consolidation of racial segregation, and especially at the beginning of the Twentieth Century, almost as if they were meant as a threat to African-Americans–who by now had been emancipated for some time from a legal point of view–so that they would not claim the full civil and political rights due them as free people.

The most significant example of this tendency is perhaps the equestrian monument of General Nathan Bedford Forrest in Memphis, inaugurated in 1905 and already taken down in 2017. The statue for sure did not celebrate a hero or a military strategist of the Confederacy. Forrest had been responsible for the slaughter of Fort Pillow, where the confederate troops under his command, on April12 1864, massacred a garrison of northern African-American soldiers after they had surrendered and laid down their arms. As if this were not enough, after the war, Forrest became one of the leading figures of the Ku Klux Klan.

An image of Columbus Circle in Manhattan at the beginning of the 20th century (From the site https://www.westsiderag.com)

Quite different is the case of the monuments to Christopher Columbus in the United States. Those who built and financed them, as a recent document of the National Italian American Foundation reminds us, were the Italian-Americans to honor the discoverer of America and, at the same time, to contribute to the legitimization of their presence in the United States, principally during years in which the immigrants from Italy were considered undesirable and inadmissible in a protestant society of Anglo-Saxon origin because of their Mediterranean origin and prevalently of Catholic devotion. The intent was not to celebrate the genocide of the Native Americans or the expropriation of their lands on the part of Europeans. Emblematic in this regard is the erection of the New York  monument to Columbus, inaugurated in 1892 and sponsored by the then director and owner of “Il Progresso Italo Americano”, Carlo Barsotti, through funds collected from the readers of what was at that time, the main daily paper in the Italian language of all the United States.

Statue of former Mayor of Philadelphia Frank Rizzo (Image from Wikimedia)

A still different case is that of  the former Philadelphia mayor Frank L. Rizzo. More than for his ability as an administrator, Rizzo is known for resorting to the iron fist against African-American organizations, and for the violations of the civil rights of their members in the years in which he  was police commissioner of the city. In the most controversial episode, though without loss of blood, when he was head of the police in 1970 Rizzo forced the members of the local cell of the Black Panthers to undress in front of the photographers’ cameras after the agents raided their headquarters simply for the purpose of humiliating them in public. Before that, he had ordered a charge against a peaceful manifestation of African-American students whose demands were to be allowed to wear African fashion in class and more courses in black studies. The charge led to the hospitalization of about fifteen demonstrators. Given the meaning of Rizzo’s public figure, then, his monument should rightly be among those that must be removed, as indeed, Mayor Jim Kenney has already decided.

The invitation to assess the motives for the erection of the statues before taking them down with an indiscriminate impetus of destruction is valid also for the European repercussions of the American phenomenon. The iconoclasm that the United States has inspired, has in fact already crossed the Atlantic, as attested by the defacing of the London memorial to Winston Churchill, and is moving on even into Italy.

Statue of Indro Montanelli in Milan, recently targeted

Here it is the statue of Indro Montanelli that has been targeted, in the Milano gardens that bear his name. What is the journalist accused of? To have boasted of having bought a sex slave, a minor, while he was fighting with the Italian troops in the conquest of Ethiopia in 1935. The monument, however, does not intend to glorify the sexual exploitation of African women, nor Italian colonialism. It was built in the same place where Montanelli was kneecapped by the Red Brigades on June 2, 1977 and honors freedom of information and those who have had the courage to support it even during the dark “Years of Lead” of Italian history. Following the same logic proposed by the critics of Montanelli’s statue, all monuments to Thomas Jefferson should also be torn down; Jefferson owned slaves and quite notoriously lived more uxorio with one of them, Sally Hemings, after his wife’s death.

For sure, there are those who already want to eliminate the third president from the American political pantheon. But, if this blind application of political correctness were to happen, we  would end up sweeping away even those who, despite their human flaws and of those of their own time, ended up promoting “a more perfect Union” in the United States as in other countries, even if at times they did it “holding their nose.”

Translation by Salvatore Rotella

 

 

 

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Stefano Luconi

Stefano Luconi

Docente di Storia degli Stati Uniti d'America, Università di Padova. Autore di numerosi libri di storia sugli italiani in America, tra i quali "From Paesani to White Ethnics: The Italian Experience in Philadelphia", ha recentemente pubblicato il volume: "L'anima nera degli Stati Uniti. Quattrocento anni di presenza afro-americana" (Cleup, 2020). Professor of US History at the University of Padua. Author of numerous books on the Italians in America, among them From Paesani to White Ethnics: the Italian Experience in Philadelphia, has just published the book: The ‘Indispensable Nation’. History of the United States from the Origins to Trump (le Monnier, 2020).

DELLO STESSO AUTORE

Mafia – USA: il mito del grande complotto che favorì lo sbarco alleato in Sicilia

Mafia – USA: il mito del grande complotto che favorì lo sbarco alleato in Sicilia

byStefano Luconi
La Giunta convalida i brogli per Adriano Cario: quanto è serio il voto all’estero?

Il voto degli italiani all’estero tra astensionismo e limiti burocratici

byStefano Luconi

A PROPOSITO DI...

Tags: Christopher ColumbusColumbus CircleColumbus StatuesIndro MontanelliItalian AmericansPublic monumentsVandalized statueswinston churchill
Previous Post

Black Lives Matter. All Lives Matter. But Who, Really, Matters? Italy, capisci?

Next Post

“Ognuno ha l’America che si merita”: il viaggio musicale di Vittorio Bongiorno

DELLO STESSO AUTORE

Quorum lontanissimo: i referendum sulla giustizia non passano

Il referendum giustizia all’estero: pochissimi al voto (e in controtendenza)

byStefano Luconi
I Biden a Uvalde. La città li incalza: “Fate qualcosa!”

Appelli di Biden al Congresso: tattica o rassegnazione?

byStefano Luconi

Latest News

Johnson, non ci fidiamo di TikTok, aveva 9 mesi per vendere

Donald Trump Pressures House Speaker Mike Johnson on Tax Hikes for the Wealthy

byRalph Savona
Nazioni Unite: Guterres accoglie con entusiasmo l’elezione di Papa Leone XIV

Nazioni Unite: Guterres accoglie con entusiasmo l’elezione di Papa Leone XIV

byStefano Vaccara

New York

Agenti USA / Ansa

Spara a un corriere di Door Dash: arrestato funzionario di New York

byGrazia Abbate
Times Square, aggrediti agenti: sospetti legati alla gang Tren de Aragua

Times Square, aggrediti agenti: sospetti legati alla gang Tren de Aragua

byMaria Nelli

Italiany

Il Prosecco italiano conquista i cuori delle donne USA

Il Prosecco italiano conquista i cuori delle donne USA

byAndrea Zaghi
Da sinistra: Elvira Raviele (Ministero delle Imprese e del Made in Italy), Fabrizio Di Michele (Console Generale d’Italia a New York), Maurizio Marinella, Luigi Liberti (Direttore Patrimonio Italiano TV), Mariangela Zappia (Ambasciatrice italiana a Washington), e Diego Puricelli Guerra (Preside Istituto Bernini De Sanctis di Napoli)

Marinella a New York: l’eleganza del Made in Italy all’Istituto Italiano di Cultura

byMonica Straniero
Next Post
Vittorio Bongiorno ai Sun Studio Memphis

"Ognuno ha l’America che si merita”: il viaggio musicale di Vittorio Bongiorno

La Voce di New York

Editor in Chief:  Giampaolo Pioli   |   English Editor: Grace Russo Bullaro   |   Founded by Stefano Vaccara

Editor in Chief:  Giampaolo Pioli
—
English Editor: Grace Russo Bullaro
—
Founded by Stefano Vaccara

  • New York
    • Eventi a New York
  • Onu
  • News
    • Primo Piano
    • Politica
    • Voto Estero
    • Economia
    • First Amendment
  • People
    • Nuovo Mondo
  • Arts
    • Arte e Design
    • Spettacolo
    • Musica
    • Libri
    • Lingua Italiana
  • Lifestyles
    • Fashion
    • Scienza e Salute
    • Sport
    • Religioni
  • Food & Wine
  • Travel
    • Italia
  • Mediterraneo
  • English
  • Search/Archive
  • About us
    • Editorial Staff
    • President
    • Administration
    • Advertising

VNY Media La Voce di New York © 2016 / 2025 — La testata fruisce dei contributi diretti editoria d.lgs. 70/2017
Main Office: 230 Park Avenue, 21floor, New York, NY 10169 | Editorial Office/Redazione: UN Secretariat Building, International Press Corps S-301, New York, NY 10017 | 112 East 71, Street Suite 1A, New York, NY 10021

VNY Media La Voce di New York © 2016 / 2025
La testata fruisce dei contributi diretti editoria d.lgs. 70/2017

Main Office: 230 Park Avenue, 21floor, New York, NY 10169 | Editorial Office/Redazione: UN Secretariat Building, International Press Corps S-301, New York, NY 10017 | 112 East 71, Street Suite 1A, New York, NY 10021

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
La Voce di New York
Gestisci Consenso
Per fornire le migliori esperienze, utilizziamo tecnologie come i cookie per memorizzare e/o accedere alle informazioni del dispositivo. Il consenso a queste tecnologie ci permetterà di elaborare dati come il comportamento di navigazione o ID unici su questo sito. Non acconsentire o ritirare il consenso può influire negativamente su alcune caratteristiche e funzioni.
Funzionale Always active
L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso sono strettamente necessari al fine legittimo di consentire l'uso di un servizio specifico esplicitamente richiesto dall'abbonato o dall'utente, o al solo scopo di effettuare la trasmissione di una comunicazione su una rete di comunicazione elettronica.
Preferenze
L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso sono necessari per lo scopo legittimo di memorizzare le preferenze che non sono richieste dall'abbonato o dall'utente.
Statistiche
L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso che viene utilizzato esclusivamente per scopi statistici. L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso che viene utilizzato esclusivamente per scopi statistici anonimi. Senza un mandato di comparizione, una conformità volontaria da parte del vostro Fornitore di Servizi Internet, o ulteriori registrazioni da parte di terzi, le informazioni memorizzate o recuperate per questo scopo da sole non possono di solito essere utilizzate per l'identificazione.
Marketing
L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso sono necessari per creare profili di utenti per inviare pubblicità, o per tracciare l'utente su un sito web o su diversi siti web per scopi di marketing simili.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
Visualizza preferenze
{title} {title} {title}
La Voce di New York
Gestisci Consenso
Per fornire le migliori esperienze, utilizziamo tecnologie come i cookie per memorizzare e/o accedere alle informazioni del dispositivo. Il consenso a queste tecnologie ci permetterà di elaborare dati come il comportamento di navigazione o ID unici su questo sito. Non acconsentire o ritirare il consenso può influire negativamente su alcune caratteristiche e funzioni.
Funzionale Always active
L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso sono strettamente necessari al fine legittimo di consentire l'uso di un servizio specifico esplicitamente richiesto dall'abbonato o dall'utente, o al solo scopo di effettuare la trasmissione di una comunicazione su una rete di comunicazione elettronica.
Preferenze
L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso sono necessari per lo scopo legittimo di memorizzare le preferenze che non sono richieste dall'abbonato o dall'utente.
Statistiche
L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso che viene utilizzato esclusivamente per scopi statistici. L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso che viene utilizzato esclusivamente per scopi statistici anonimi. Senza un mandato di comparizione, una conformità volontaria da parte del vostro Fornitore di Servizi Internet, o ulteriori registrazioni da parte di terzi, le informazioni memorizzate o recuperate per questo scopo da sole non possono di solito essere utilizzate per l'identificazione.
Marketing
L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso sono necessari per creare profili di utenti per inviare pubblicità, o per tracciare l'utente su un sito web o su diversi siti web per scopi di marketing simili.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
Visualizza preferenze
{title} {title} {title}
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • New York
  • Onu
  • News
    • Primo Piano
    • Politica
    • Economia
    • First Amendment
  • Arts
    • Arte e Design
    • Spettacolo
    • Musica
    • Libri
  • Lifestyles
    • Fashion
    • Scienza e Salute
    • Sport
    • Religioni
  • Food & Wine
    • Cucina Italiana
  • Travel
    • Italia
  • Video
  • English
    • Arts
    • Business
    • Entertainment
    • Food & Wine
    • Letters
    • Lifestyles
    • Mediterranean
    • New York
    • News
  • Subscribe for only $6/Year

© 2016/2022 VNY Media La Voce di New York

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?