President: Giampaolo Pioli   |   Editor in Chief: Stefano Vaccara

  • Login
VNY La Voce di New York

The First Italian English Digital Daily Newspaper in the US

  • English Edition
  • Letters
  • New York
  • U.N.
  • News
  • People
  • Arts
  • Lifestyles
  • Food & Wine
  • Travel
  • Italian Edition
No Result
View All Result
VNY
  • English Edition
  • Letters
  • New York
  • U.N.
  • News
  • People
  • Arts
  • Lifestyles
  • Food & Wine
  • Travel
  • Italian Edition
No Result
View All Result
VNY La Voce di New York
No Result
View All Result
in
News
October 3, 2020
in
News
October 3, 2020
0

After the Disastrous Presidential Debate We’re Better Off Sticking with Machiavelli

Trump and Biden disappointing? To educate on democracy isn't indoctrination, it’s a viable and exciting enterprise and our principal responsibility as educators

Stefano AlbertinibyStefano Albertini
Il dibattito presidenziale è stato un disastro? Meglio far politica ancora con Machiavelli

1338-1339: The Effects of Good Government in the City. A series of frescoes created by Lorenzetti, a contemporary of the Governo dei Nove in Siena. The artist wanted to convey a representation of government and its positive effects in the life and society of Siena.

Time: 3 mins read

In Italiano

The US presidential election is just over a month away and the eyes of the world are on that fateful moment that has the potential to change the destinies of millions of people far beyond the borders of the United States. The almost unanimous reaction after the first debate on Tuesday was one of great disappointment, if not disgust, at the foul spectacle offered by the two challengers for the most powerful elective office in the world. The responsibility for the disastrous outcome of the debate should not be equally divided between the two candidates. Trump’s absolute disregard for the most basic rules of good manners and his shameless bullying behavior would have dragged Cicero, Savonarola, and Mahatma Ghandi into the gutter of insults, lies, slander and disconnected phrases.

During the debate

Many of my American friends have wondered if this form of political confrontation still makes sense and if it wouldn’t have been better for Biden to walk away in the middle of the event. Others argue that it would be better to cancel upcoming debates altogether. In truth, for years there have been doubts about the actual usefulness of this very American political tradition that used to make more sense in less polarized times, and when the sources of information were fewer and more reliable. In the era of Twitter, when candidates seem to communicate directly with their electorate without mediation and without filters, the electoral duels that score hits in the form of memorable phrases seem inexorably obsolete.

I am teaching a course on Machiavelli in the historical and political context of the Italian Renaissance to about forty New York University students, and I thought it appropriate to suspend my cycle of lessons and instead involve the students in an exercise in democratic dialectics, in the form of the debate. American schools and universities foster a glorious tradition of dialectical education that includes debate teams with tournaments and coaches, as if it were a real sport. It is a training ground for the use of words that teaches students to speak in public, to express their ideas clearly, to listen to the reasons of others, to counter in a firm yet polite manner. All values put into serious crisis by the last presidential debate.

Niccolò Machiavelli, a leading political figure in Renaissance Florence.

And so, I asked my students to take sides and choose one of the three parties that dominated the Florentine scene at the end of the 15th century: the Palleschi who wanted a formally republican government under the discreet yet strict control of the Medici family, the Piagnoni who supported the regime of almost direct and theocratic democracy of Fra’ Girolamo Savonarola, and the Arrabbiati who demanded the return of the ancient republican institutions under the control of the economic oligarchy.

I invited the students to meet for their party’s convention and to write a short programmatic document on internal, foreign and economic policy. At the end of the conventions we proceeded to the debate during which the representatives of the three parties answered the precise questions asked by me and my colleague, acting as moderators. The students, who were first surprised by the unusual format of the lesson, got carried away and were thrilled by the challenge. They overwhelmed me with their competence and ability. They did not insult or interrupt each other; they did not go off topic, and four of them even changed their minds (and party) during the debate.

For almost two hours we never mentioned Biden or Trump, only Soderini, Machiavelli, Leone X and Savonarola, but it was a great exercise in practical democracy. Educating on the process of democracy is not indoctrination, it is a feasible and exciting undertaking and it is our main duty as educators.

 

 

 

 

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Stefano Albertini

Stefano Albertini

Sono nato a Bozzolo, in provincia di Mantova. Mi sono laureato in lettere a Parma per poi passare dall'altra parte dell'oceano dove ho conseguito un Master all'Università della Virginia e un Ph.D. a Stanford. Dal 1994 insegno alla New York University e dal 1998 dirigo la Casa Italiana Zerilli Marimò dello stesso ateneo. Alla Casa io e la mia squadra organizziamo un centinaio di eventi all'anno tra mostre, conferenze, concerti e spettacoli teatrali. La mia passione (di famiglia) rimane però l'insegnamento: ho creato un corso sulla rappresentazione cinematografica della storia italiana e uno, molto seguito, su Machiavelli. D'estate dirigo il programma di NYU a Firenze, ma continuo ad avere un rapporto stretto e viscerale col mio paese di origine e l'anno scorso ho fondato l'Accademia del dialetto bozzolese proprio per contribuire a conservarne e trasmettere la cultura.

DELLO STESSO AUTORE

Quella volta che sudai tanto intervistando Franco Battiato alla New York University

Quella volta che sudai tanto intervistando Franco Battiato alla New York University

byStefano Albertini
Econ-comiche: Trump, Biden e il passaggio della torcia alla Casa Bianca

Discorso agli italiani sul crimine di Trump nel tempio sacro della democrazia USA

byStefano Albertini

A PROPOSITO DI...

Tags: Biden 2020Cosimo de MediciElection 2020FlorenceNiccolò MachiavelliPolitical theoryPoliticsPresidential debatesRenaissanceSavonarolaTrump 2020USA 2020
Previous Post

Matteo Salvini alla sbarra: tutti d’accordo sul “Processo silenziato”

Next Post

Neoitaliani: un manifesto per il popolo che è di tutto e molto di più

Discussion about this post

DELLO STESSO AUTORE

L’arte musicale che annulla spazio e tempo per unire contro la discriminazione razziale

The Musical Art that Erases Time and Space to Unite Against Racism

byStefano Albertini
L’arte musicale che annulla spazio e tempo per unire contro la discriminazione razziale

L’arte musicale che annulla spazio e tempo per unire contro la discriminazione razziale

byStefano Albertini

Latest News

“Abbiamo sbagliato”: le drammatiche parole della polizia del Texas

“Abbiamo sbagliato”: le drammatiche parole della polizia del Texas

byMassimo Jaus
Cardinal Zuppi New Head of Italian Bishops Conference

‘Italy Church Too’ Organization Says It Was Rebuffed by Zuppi, New CEI Head Responds

byLa Voce di New York

New York

A Bryant Park torna la lirica: va in scena “Il Barbiere di Siviglia”

A Bryant Park torna la lirica: va in scena “Il Barbiere di Siviglia”

byLa Voce di New York
A New York afro e ispanici sono sempre i più fermati dalla polizia

A New York afro e ispanici sono sempre i più fermati dalla polizia

byLa Voce di New York

Italiany

Lo staff di In Scena!

In Scena! Sipario sul festival del teatro italiano a New York che reagisce alla pandemia

byManuela Caracciolo
Il matrimonio Made in Italy tra Kourtney Kardashian e Travis Barker

Il matrimonio Made in Italy tra Kourtney Kardashian e Travis Barker

byLa Voce di New York
Next Post
Neoitaliani: un manifesto per il popolo che è di tutto e molto di più

Neoitaliani: un manifesto per il popolo che è di tutto e molto di più

La Voce di New York

President: Giampaolo Pioli   |   Editor in Chief: Stefano Vaccara

  • New York
    • Eventi
  • Onu
  • News
    • Primo Piano
    • Politica
    • Voto Estero
    • Economia
    • First Amendment
  • People
    • EXPAT
  • Arts
    • Arte e Design
    • Spettacolo
    • Musica
    • Libri
    • Lingua Italiana
  • Lifestyles
    • Fashion
    • Scienza e Salute
    • Sport
    • Religioni
  • Food & Wine
  • Travel
    • Italia
  • Mediterraneo
  • English
  • Search/Archive
  • About us
    • Editorial Staff
    • President
    • Administration
    • Advertising

VNY Media La Voce di New York © 2016 - 2022
Main Office: 230 Park Avenue, 21floor, New York, NY 10169 | Editorial Office/Redazione: UN Secretariat Building, International Press Corps S-301, New York, NY 10017

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • New York
  • Onu
  • News
    • Primo Piano
    • Politica
    • Economia
    • First Amendment
  • Arts
    • Arte e Design
    • Spettacolo
    • Musica
    • Libri
  • Lingua Italiana
  • Lifestyles
    • Fashion
    • Scienza e Salute
    • Sport
    • Religioni
  • Food & Wine
    • Cucina Italiana
  • Travel
    • Italia
  • English

© 2016/2022 VNY Media La Voce di New York

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In