Founded by Stefano Vaccara

Subscribe for only $6/Year
  • Login

Editor in Chief: Giampaolo Pioli

VNY La Voce di New York

The First Italian English Digital Daily in the US

English Editor: Grace Russo Bullaro

  • English Edition
  • Letters
  • New York
  • U.N.
  • News
  • People
  • Entertainment
  • Arts
  • Lifestyles
  • Food & Wine
  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Italian Edition
No Result
View All Result
VNY
  • English Edition
  • Letters
  • New York
  • U.N.
  • News
  • People
  • Entertainment
  • Arts
  • Lifestyles
  • Food & Wine
  • Travel
  • Sports
  • Italian Edition
No Result
View All Result
VNY La Voce di New York
No Result
View All Result
in Homepage
May 18, 2017
in Homepage
May 18, 2017
0

Donald Trump and the Era of Post-Truth

Across historical eras people have asked: what is "truth"? Postmodernism invented the concept of "fake news" and relative truth before Donald Trump

Grace Russo BullarobyGrace Russo Bullaro
trump truth

Trump during the Presidential campaign (Imagine from www.foxhedgehog.com)

Time: 6 mins read

Every era has its own concept and definition of “truth”. The Victorians had a reverence for it and believed that it emanated from God. When wars were fought, your side won because you had “truth” on your side. Belief in its existence went along with belief in institutions and moral and social certainties. It also implied faith that humanity would make moral progress in tandem with economic progress. This was the Era of the Gilded Age and its optimism.

These certainties were buried by the cataclysm that was World War I and the disillusion that ensued. The resulting Modernist movement, though usually associated principally with the arts, offered its own definition of Truth, moral and otherwise. The carnage of the “Great War” pulled the rug out from under religion, philosophy, and the arts. God was dead (a slogan that was and is, simplistically attributed to Nietzsche), humanity was proved to be brutal and inhumane, and conventional boundaries in the arts and in life, were now to be broken. Nihilism supplanted the certainties of the Gilded Age. The consequence was a “carpe diem” mentality that gave birth to the age of the Bohemian lifestyle, and the disenchantment of the “Lost Generation” portrayed in Hemingway’s The Sun Also Rises.

World War II only deepened the nihilistic mood and gave rise to atheistic Existentialism, a philosophy that was mostly reviled and misunderstood by the public, but whose condemnation of any faith was understandable in the wake of the second World War that had just ended. The first one had been hailed as “the war to end all wars,” yet the second that had followed on its heels had been even more devastating and demoralizing. Existentialism explicitly challenged the possibility of objective truth, its popularizer, Jean-Paul Sartre asking, “does objective truth exist?” (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy). Over the decades the erosion in private and public faith has been constant. The cynicism of the Vietnam era for example, also did its share to undermine the authority and credibility of Government, its institutions, and the notion of “truth”.

Politics, the economy, cultural movements, these are all intertwined and comprehensively they shape and constitute an “era” or, to use an old-fashioned word, a “zeitgeist”. The end of World War II ushered in the age of Postmodernism. So, what is Postmodernism and how does it illuminate the current definition of “truth”? According to one source that aims to define philosophies, “Postmodernists do not attempt to refine their thoughts about what is right or wrong, true or false, good or evil. They believe that there isn’t such a thing as absolute truth. A postmodernist views the world outside of themselves as being in error, that is, other people’s truth becomes indistinguishable from error. Therefore, no one has the authority to define truth or impose upon others his idea of moral right and wrong” (Postmodern Openings).  Another source informs us that, “[Post-modernists] believe that truth is relative and ‘truth’ is up to each individual to determine for himself” (AllPhilosophy). In short, what we have here is a definition of “fake news” and “post-truth” before Donald Trump popularized them.

Photo: Pixabay

While “post-truth” is a word that was first used in an essay in The Nation in 1992, it has become ubiquitous in the post 2016 election era. The Oxford Dictionary declared it to be the word of the year for 2016 and defined it as, “Relating to or denoting circumstances in which objective facts are less influential in shaping public opinion than appeals to emotion and personal belief.” Thus the fact that both the FBI and the CIA, along with 17 other intelligence organizations whose responsibility is to investigate suspicious events, affirmed that “Russia intervened in the 2016 election in part to help Donald Trump win the White House” is meaningless to Donald Trump and his supporters since they themselves have other convictions.

Yet Trump and his supporters are not alone in their total disdain for “facts”. “Post-truth” was used pervasively to describe not only the Donald Trump presidential campaign but also the Brexit movement, both of whose success was ascribed by many to the systematic misrepresentation of truth. Increasingly we note that people on both sides of the political spectrum prefer to speak from a postmodernist position of subjectivity–in other words, their own opinion, but without having recourse to “facts” because they don’t believe that “fact” or “truth” besides their own “facts” and “truths” exist. In short, for these people, their own “truth” is truer than anything previously reported as “fact” and the hackneyed postmodernist slogan of “perception IS reality” wins out.

Photo: Wikimedia Commons

Let’s look at another example. The Justice Department investigation into the shooting of Michael Brown in Ferguson, Missouri in 2015 concluded that, “Physical and forensic evidence in fact contradict claims by witnesses who have maintained that Brown had his hands up, above his waist when Wilson shot him”. Despite the categorical nature of this declaration, it failed absolutely to convince Brown’s supporters that this was a truthful finding. Indeed, despite this judgement a “Hands Up-Don’t Shoot” movement emerged and continues to be a by-word for police corruption and abuse.

“Facts” have no sway when emotions run strong. Subjectivity consistently “trumps” objectivity. It is perhaps significant that one of the most recent interpretive approaches to the arts is “Affect theory.” In one essay we read that, “After long neglect, in recent decades, emotion—or, more generally, affect—has become a major concern in literary study, as well as philosophy, psychology, and elsewhere.” We could add that this seems to have become the predominant approach to interpreting “reality”, political events, and in general, the “news” as well.

In my personal experience as a professor teaching seminars in which social and political issues are discussed, it never ceases to astonish me how a student will argue for a personal opinion from a position of ignorance. In the seminar room, which arguably serves as a microcosm of what ought to be the informed public, it is not uncommon in these days of incivility to see tempers flare when one person disagrees with another, yet patently neither one seems to have accurate information about the issues being debated. Here we do not refer to information that can be “interpreted” but rather indisputable information such as, “what is the First Amendment and what does it actually state?” Much like the daily spectacle we witness on television in the political talk shows, these students will argue to the death that theirs is the only truth despite the incontrovertible evidence that their argument is built on a faulty premise.

If truth is now an illusion, or at least so relative as to be stretched beyond any boundaries of reality, then what are lies? The Orwellian euphemisms abound. A person may be guilty of having spoken an “untruth” or an “alternative fact,” or of having “misspoken” or “misremembered”. Anything that you do not agree with is, thanks to Donald Trump’s ingenious trickery, “fake news”. Reputable sources have been replaced by vague reports made by “anonymous”, or justified by empty shells such as “everyone knows”, “they say”, or “I have a friend who said…”. This last one is one of Donald Trump’s favorites, as in one fell swoop he successfully manages to abrogate both accountability of sources and credibility of expertise.

We may very well agree with Quartz media which succinctly suggests, “post-truth could also be defined by a simple one-word synonym: propaganda”. The author explains that in today’s world of political speak, “advertising, sponsored content, public diplomacy, fake news, and post-truth content…”are all variations on what used to be called propaganda.

Recently there has been a lot of talk about “The New Sincerity”, defined as “a combination of irony and sincerity to form a new movement of astonishing power”. Notoriously hazy to grasp for various reasons, it has been popularized by Jesse Thorn, the host of PRI’s The Sound of Young America. To those who find it a difficult theory to pin down, Thorn suggests, “just think of Evel Knievel. Let’s be frank. There’s no way to appreciate Evel Knievel literally. Evel is the kind of man who defies even fiction, because the reality is too over the top. …Simply put, Evel Knievel boggles the mind. But by the same token, he isn’t to be taken ironically, either” (Wikipedia—The New Sincerity). Evel Knievel or Donald Trump? Thorn could just as easily be describing Donald Trump.

According to many pundits we are headed towards a new Nihilism. Daily we are barraged with news of ongoing wars fought over flagrantly false pretexts and escalating nuclear threats on the global scale, racial discord and bitter polarization at home, an embattled presidency that instigates fear and insecurity, a President whose aim seems to be to undermine rather than bolster confidence in the institutions, a media whose credibility seems to have collapsed under the weight of its own partisanship and bias. When truth is so painful, is it little wonder that we take refuge in the age of “post-truth”?

 

grace-russo-bullaroGrace Russo Bullaro, was born in Italy and immigrated to the USA at a young age. For the last twenty years she has been teaching at City University of New York. Her research and publications focus on socio-political and cultural issues that drive changes in society.

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Grace Russo Bullaro

Grace Russo Bullaro

Grace Russo Bullaro holds a Ph.D. in Comparative Literature. After teaching for more than 25 years in the English Department at City University of New York (Lehman College) is now Emerita. Her academic interests include political, cultural and intellectual movements, specifically, the interface of politics and the arts. She has written many books and articles on subjects related to those areas.

DELLO STESSO AUTORE

Pope Francis, Political and Spiritual Powerhouse Leader, Dead at 88

byGrace Russo Bullaro
Il Papa nomina una donna capo Dicastero vita consacrata

Addio a Papa Francesco: il Santo Padre si è spento a 88 anni

byGrace Russo Bullaro

A PROPOSITO DI...

Tags: Donald Trumppost-truthTruth
Previous Post

Genitori italiani a New York: quale istruzione per i nostri figli?

Next Post

How Wally Lamb’s Italian-ness Inspires Everything He Writes

DELLO STESSO AUTORE

Grande attesa per l’intervista (a pagamento) di Elon Musk a Donald Trump

The Technocracy of Elon Musk: A New Era of Governance or the Folly of a Teenager?

byGrace Russo Bullaro
Casey DeSantis May Run for Florida Gov. Now that Ron’s Term Will End

Casey DeSantis May Run for Florida Gov. Now that Ron’s Term Will End

byGrace Russo Bullaro

Latest News

SWAIA Native Fashion Week 2025: Indigenous Fashion Takes Over Santa Fe

SWAIA Native Fashion Week 2025: Indigenous Fashion Takes Over Santa Fe

byFilomena Troiano
Trump benedice Leone XIV: l’America ha “preso” anche il Vaticano

Trump benedice Leone XIV: l’America ha “preso” anche il Vaticano

byGlauco Maggi

New York

“Trump Effect” Tanks Tourism in New York City: 400k Fewer Visitors in 2025

“Trump Effect” Tanks Tourism in New York City: 400k Fewer Visitors in 2025

byDaniele Di Bartolomei
Agenti USA / Ansa

Spara a un corriere di Door Dash: arrestato funzionario di New York

byGrazia Abbate

Italiany

Il Prosecco italiano conquista i cuori delle donne USA

Il Prosecco italiano conquista i cuori delle donne USA

byAndrea Zaghi
Da sinistra: Elvira Raviele (Ministero delle Imprese e del Made in Italy), Fabrizio Di Michele (Console Generale d’Italia a New York), Maurizio Marinella, Luigi Liberti (Direttore Patrimonio Italiano TV), Mariangela Zappia (Ambasciatrice italiana a Washington), e Diego Puricelli Guerra (Preside Istituto Bernini De Sanctis di Napoli)

Marinella a New York: l’eleganza del Made in Italy all’Istituto Italiano di Cultura

byMonica Straniero
Next Post
How Wally Lamb’s Italian-ness Inspires Everything He Writes

How Wally Lamb’s Italian-ness Inspires Everything He Writes

La Voce di New York

Editor in Chief:  Giampaolo Pioli   |   English Editor: Grace Russo Bullaro   |   Founded by Stefano Vaccara

Editor in Chief:  Giampaolo Pioli
—
English Editor: Grace Russo Bullaro
—
Founded by Stefano Vaccara

  • New York
    • Eventi a New York
  • Onu
  • News
    • Primo Piano
    • Politica
    • Voto Estero
    • Economia
    • First Amendment
  • People
    • Nuovo Mondo
  • Arts
    • Arte e Design
    • Spettacolo
    • Musica
    • Libri
    • Lingua Italiana
  • Lifestyles
    • Fashion
    • Scienza e Salute
    • Sport
    • Religioni
  • Food & Wine
  • Travel
    • Italia
  • Mediterraneo
  • English
  • Search/Archive
  • About us
    • Editorial Staff
    • President
    • Administration
    • Advertising

VNY Media La Voce di New York © 2016 / 2025 — La testata fruisce dei contributi diretti editoria d.lgs. 70/2017
Main Office: 230 Park Avenue, 21floor, New York, NY 10169 | Editorial Office/Redazione: UN Secretariat Building, International Press Corps S-301, New York, NY 10017 | 112 East 71, Street Suite 1A, New York, NY 10021

VNY Media La Voce di New York © 2016 / 2025
La testata fruisce dei contributi diretti editoria d.lgs. 70/2017

Main Office: 230 Park Avenue, 21floor, New York, NY 10169 | Editorial Office/Redazione: UN Secretariat Building, International Press Corps S-301, New York, NY 10017 | 112 East 71, Street Suite 1A, New York, NY 10021

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
La Voce di New York
Gestisci Consenso
Per fornire le migliori esperienze, utilizziamo tecnologie come i cookie per memorizzare e/o accedere alle informazioni del dispositivo. Il consenso a queste tecnologie ci permetterà di elaborare dati come il comportamento di navigazione o ID unici su questo sito. Non acconsentire o ritirare il consenso può influire negativamente su alcune caratteristiche e funzioni.
Funzionale Always active
L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso sono strettamente necessari al fine legittimo di consentire l'uso di un servizio specifico esplicitamente richiesto dall'abbonato o dall'utente, o al solo scopo di effettuare la trasmissione di una comunicazione su una rete di comunicazione elettronica.
Preferenze
L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso sono necessari per lo scopo legittimo di memorizzare le preferenze che non sono richieste dall'abbonato o dall'utente.
Statistiche
L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso che viene utilizzato esclusivamente per scopi statistici. L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso che viene utilizzato esclusivamente per scopi statistici anonimi. Senza un mandato di comparizione, una conformità volontaria da parte del vostro Fornitore di Servizi Internet, o ulteriori registrazioni da parte di terzi, le informazioni memorizzate o recuperate per questo scopo da sole non possono di solito essere utilizzate per l'identificazione.
Marketing
L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso sono necessari per creare profili di utenti per inviare pubblicità, o per tracciare l'utente su un sito web o su diversi siti web per scopi di marketing simili.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
Visualizza preferenze
{title} {title} {title}
La Voce di New York
Gestisci Consenso
Per fornire le migliori esperienze, utilizziamo tecnologie come i cookie per memorizzare e/o accedere alle informazioni del dispositivo. Il consenso a queste tecnologie ci permetterà di elaborare dati come il comportamento di navigazione o ID unici su questo sito. Non acconsentire o ritirare il consenso può influire negativamente su alcune caratteristiche e funzioni.
Funzionale Always active
L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso sono strettamente necessari al fine legittimo di consentire l'uso di un servizio specifico esplicitamente richiesto dall'abbonato o dall'utente, o al solo scopo di effettuare la trasmissione di una comunicazione su una rete di comunicazione elettronica.
Preferenze
L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso sono necessari per lo scopo legittimo di memorizzare le preferenze che non sono richieste dall'abbonato o dall'utente.
Statistiche
L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso che viene utilizzato esclusivamente per scopi statistici. L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso che viene utilizzato esclusivamente per scopi statistici anonimi. Senza un mandato di comparizione, una conformità volontaria da parte del vostro Fornitore di Servizi Internet, o ulteriori registrazioni da parte di terzi, le informazioni memorizzate o recuperate per questo scopo da sole non possono di solito essere utilizzate per l'identificazione.
Marketing
L'archiviazione tecnica o l'accesso sono necessari per creare profili di utenti per inviare pubblicità, o per tracciare l'utente su un sito web o su diversi siti web per scopi di marketing simili.
Manage options Manage services Manage {vendor_count} vendors Read more about these purposes
Visualizza preferenze
{title} {title} {title}
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • New York
  • Onu
  • News
    • Primo Piano
    • Politica
    • Economia
    • First Amendment
  • Arts
    • Arte e Design
    • Spettacolo
    • Musica
    • Libri
  • Lifestyles
    • Fashion
    • Scienza e Salute
    • Sport
    • Religioni
  • Food & Wine
    • Cucina Italiana
  • Travel
    • Italia
  • Video
  • English
    • Arts
    • Business
    • Entertainment
    • Food & Wine
    • Letters
    • Lifestyles
    • Mediterranean
    • New York
    • News
  • Subscribe for only $6/Year

© 2016/2022 VNY Media La Voce di New York

Are you sure want to unlock this post?
Unlock left : 0
Are you sure want to cancel subscription?