Just days before the start of the Conclave set to begin on May 7 to elect the successor of Pope Francis, who passed away on April 21, a new controversy has engulfed U.S. President Donald Trump. An image released by the official White House social media accounts shows the President dressed as the Pontiff: a white cassock, golden crucifix, and a blessing gesture. The AI-generated photomontage was also shared by the GOP leader himself on his Truth Social profile, sparking a wave of global reactions.
Social media quickly split in opinion. Some called the gesture “disturbing” and “disrespectful,” accusing the White House of lacking sensitivity during a delicate moment for the Catholic world. Others interpreted it as a tongue-in-cheek provocation, consistent with the President’s communication style. However, the issue soon took on broader dimensions. In recent days, Trump had already jokingly hinted at the idea of becoming the next Pope. During a meeting with reporters, he claimed that becoming head of the Catholic Church would be “his first choice,” convinced that “no one could do it better.” Statements that might have been dismissed as mere jokes now, in light of the photomontage, seem to fuel a deliberate communication strategy.
— The White House (@WhiteHouse) May 3, 2025
That’s not all. In a recent interview, the President voiced his support for Cardinal Timothy Dolan, the Archbishop of New York, suggesting he would be a figure “well suited to the role.” Dolan is known for his traditionalist views and his closeness to conservative U.S. circles, enjoying support among the Republican electorate. However, his name appears to have limited appeal among many of the cardinals from the Global South, who now represent a growing and influential force in the international ecclesiastical landscape.
Dolan, who also took part in the 2013 conclave that elected Pope Francis, will be one of the ten American cardinals present this time as well. His connection to the U.S. President is also marked by a notable precedent: he led the prayer at Trump’s inauguration.
The attendance of the American head of state and First Lady Melania at Pope Francis’ funeral has sparked further speculation, particularly regarding the President’s attire. Breaking with tradition, Trump chose a navy blue suit instead of the customary black, a choice that many interpreted as yet another signal of defiance.
