Last Thursday, religious contention surrounded the funeral of Cecilia Gentili, a transgender activist and actress, at St. Patrick’s Cathedral. The service sparked profound disapproval from the Archdiocese of New York and has been described as “scandalous” and “sacrilegious.” The event was attended by over a thousand mourners and led to an unprecedented Mass of Reparation to address what the church viewed as a desecration of sacred rites during a particularly holy time in the Lent season.
The late Gentili, known for her staunch advocacy for transgender rights, sex workers, and individuals with HIV, was commemorated in a service that included unconventional eulogies and attire. Outrage ensued from the church officials as the attendees, many from the LGBTQ+ community, paid tribute in a manner that the Archdiocese contends mocked the sanctity of the church and the Lenten period of repentance.
In response to the ceremony, which included a controversial homage to Gentili likening her to a saint, the Very Reverend Enrique Salvo expressed the church’s indignation over the unexpected turn the funeral had taken. Cardinal Timothy Dolan directed a subsequent mass to seek atonement for the incident.
Gentili’s family and supporters defended the service, highlighting her role as a compassionate figure who reached out to marginalized individuals. They accused the church of hypocrisy and anti-trans sentiment, asserting that the true scandal lies in the church’s refusal to embrace all walks of life.
The event has reignited discussions on the church’s stance towards the LGBTQ+ community, reminiscent of past protests during the height of the HIV/AIDS epidemic. Despite the church’s condemnation, many attendees of the cathedral’s services felt the funeral aligned with a message of inclusivity and unconditional love, core tenets they believe are at the heart of the Catholic faith.
